#12 Joshua Carmichael

[What'sinaname]

Looked good and got better throughout the game. The only surprise was the lack of depth in his kicks. Is that just him?

[slangman]

Looked good and got better throughout the game. The only surprise was the lack of depth in his kicks. Is that just him?

That 55m kick to Mihocek had plenty of depth.

[Woods Of Ypres]

nice first game, got caught early but stood up well in tackles and has a nice kick too, a lot to like.

[What'sinaname]

Looked good and got better throughout the game. The only surprise was the lack of depth in his kicks. Is that just him?

That 55m kick to Mihocek had plenty of depth.

I just watch the highlights. He was about 55m out when he kicked the ball and Mihocek marked it 25m from goal.

[What'sinaname]

The maths would say it's not a 30m kick, but it's closer to 30m than 55m

[slangman]

The maths would say it's not a 30m kick, but it's closer to 30m than 55m

I watched relay and that kick imho went at least 45m.
Either way, I thought that his kicks were standard AFL level for penetration.

[Magpietothemax]

I thought it was a fine debut. And I reckon that he was robbed of a goal. That shot of his looked like it was over the line when the North defender got to it.

[piffdog]

I thought it was a fine debut. And I reckon that he was robbed of a goal. That shot of his looked like it was over the line when the North defender got to it.

Yesss - was just about to post the same thing. Will need to inspect that one in the replay. Would have been some goal.

[What'sinaname]

I thought it was a fine debut. And I reckon that he was robbed of a goal. That shot of his looked like it was over the line when the North defender got to it.

Yesss - was just about to post the same thing. Will need to inspect that one in the replay. Would have been some goal.

Regardless, it shows his football smarts. And that's a great sign.

Not expecting too much from him this year, but 2023.....

[Cam]

The maths would say it's not a 30m kick, but it's closer to 30m than 55m

I watched relay and that kick imho went at least 45m.
Either way, I thought that his kicks were standard AFL level for penetration.

He kicked it across the arc, not straight to Checkers. It was a perfectly weighted kick and Checkers was able to run onto it.

[Jezza]

Good performance by a first gamer.

The kick to Checkers in the 3rd was excellent. One of the highlights of the day.

[Bucks5]

Didn't he also almost kick a miracle goal? I am not so sure it was touched before crossing the line but no score review was called.

[Jezza]

^ Yes. Unfortunately, there was no score review as you said.

[David]

I watched it again and, on the slow-mo replay, it did look like the North defender touched it right on the line. A pity as it was an incredible attempt by Carmichael. At the ground, I was frustrated with Mihocek for trying to shepherd it through and not getting a boot to it himself, but watching the broadcast I can understand a little better why he did it!

[Skids]

Plenty to like here, what a great mid season pick up!

Mid season draft specialists!