Maynard incident > Maynard rule > Brayshaw retirement

[robevpau1]

Definitely not commenting on whether this impacted the Maynard incident, but Brayshaw’s head collided with Adams 4.30 prior to the BM event. It will be interesting to see if this is a relevant discussion point raised by lawyers in the tribunal case this week.- Tom Browne

https://twitter.com/i/status/1700082329488851104


Maybe already concussed prior to the BM event?

[Piesnchess]

All Bruz had to do was put his arms out in front of him to protect himself. As soon as he turned, he was fkd

Ever tried to turn your body at full pace, flying thru the air, full pelt , in a split second, to smother the ball, nah, thought not.

Exactly. Bruz chose to turn his body. He chose the more difficult action.

Jeezus thank Christ you would never be on my Jury, shit, I meant he was flying thru the air, contact was unavoidable, he could not turn his body to avoid collision , smart arse.

[What'sinaname]

Ever tried to turn your body at full pace, flying thru the air, full pelt , in a split second, to smother the ball, nah, thought not.

I am sure if Pickett did this to Naicos, you'd all be arguing that it was a football action. Right? Thought not!

[eddiesmith]

^
Yet if that happened, Pickett wouldn’t be missing a grand final

[What'sinaname]

[quote="eddiesmith"]Yet if that happened, Pickett wouldn’t be missing a grand final

[What'sinaname]

and to make matters worse, the Blues will smash the Swans

[Haff]

and to make matters worse, the Blues will smash the Swans

Swans are just making up the numbers so yep. Will be bruise free.

[Haff]

Taken a breath. I don’t think what’s her face has is a problem, it’s just part of their process and bad reporting. Not taking any of this Gill stepped in bs into account.

Exactly as anyone who knows the grading process thought. Pies would know this was what was happening and would have already been working on a rock solid defence.

If he doesn’t get off, might as well put bibs on and play netball.

[Mr Miyagi]

Definitely not commenting on whether this impacted the Maynard incident, but Brayshaw’s head collided with Adams 4.30 prior to the BM event. It will be interesting to see if this is a relevant discussion point raised by lawyers in the tribunal case this week.- Tom Browne

https://twitter.com/i/status/1700082329488851104


Maybe already concussed prior to the BM event?

Well that’s interesting! Be funny if Bruz gets off and Melbourne get fined for not following concussion protocols. UPDATE: tweet deleted!!!

[lazzadesilva]

[Mr Miyagi]

Curnow will get half a dozen free kicks 30m out directly in front

[swoop42]

If Maynard isn't cleared to play I'd back the club taking it to court because it's clear he's being held to a different set of rules to that of Cripps, Duncan and McCartin.

Two of those cases occurred this season, while Cripps was cleared and free to win the Brownlow just 12 months back.

Those aren't rulings from a different era.

Personally I don't think the AFL has a leg to stand on if credibility and fairness still matters.

[What'sinaname]

If Maynard isn't cleared to play I'd back the club taking it to court because it's clear he's being held to a different set of rules to that of Cripps, Duncan and McCartin.

Two of those cases occurred this season, while Cripps was cleared and free to win the Brownlow just 12 months back.

Those aren't rulings from a different era.

Personally I don't think the AFL has a leg to stand on if credibility and fairness still matters.

Cripps was suspended for 2 weeks. His legal team got him off on a technicality which has subsequently been closed by the AFL. So using Cripps as an example doesn't work.

[Mr Miyagi]

Tom Browne just deleted his Twitter post saying Brayshaw knocked heads with Adams a few minutes before the Maynard incident

[duggieboy]

[quote="Mr Miyagi"]Tom Browne just deleted his Twitter post saying Brayshaw knocked heads with Adams a few minutes before the Maynard incident