Trade Targets ~ Free Agency & MSD player discussion

[SLORT]

^I actually think Mcdonald from Melbourne would be good for a year or two, though there were some rumours about his teammate Tomlinson (also over 30).

[Presti35]

No interest in Tomlinson from me. I can see anything from his time at the Dees that says to me we should go for him. 31yo, injuries following him. Has got to be a better option out there. I'd pass on Tom McDonald too, he's already signed on for 2025 anyway.

After the GWS boys, I dont think there's much left in the FA/UFA market. 195cm defender Jake Kolodjashnij is 29, but still unsigned. Very doubtful he doesnt stay with the Cats tho.

[SLORT]

I'm personally wondering whether we can find / make a Jake Waterman of our own. At only 191cm he reminds me of the heyday of full-forwards (Ablett 185cm, Brereton 186cm, Dunstall 188cm, Lockett 191cm, Carey 192cm, Lloyd 192cm).
It's so weird to me the fixation now for the 196cm+ forwards who are ultra mobile and athletic. Seems that most of them end up breaking down regularly and hate body contact.

I really do miss the days of the shorter, burly full forward with good leading and chest marking ability and straight kicking. So funny that we now get excited about forwards that can barely average 2 goals a game.
Was watching highlights of a Vic vs SA game with Brereton, Dunstall, and Lockett. Those were the days...

[Newelly]

^
Frequently flooded forward lines has necessitated taller forwards with the negative effect of reduced goalkicking accuracy.

With taller players the ball has further to travel to foot once it leaves the hand and creates greater chance of a miskick. So I have been told.

[stui magpie]

^

Dunstall, Lockett and Lloyd relied on fast leading from the goal square in the days before there were 34 players in the forward 50 and key backs were the same height as them.

Carey was special and Ablett was a freak.

I'd prefer to have a 195-197cm FF who can lead the way they used to back in the day and fight like buggery at ground level than a 200+cm FF who just gets worked under the ball at contests by a smaller opponent. 197cm is the new 188cm.

[Pies2016]

I'm personally wondering whether we can find / make a Jake Waterman of our own. At only 191cm he reminds me of the heyday of full-forwards (Ablett 185cm, Brereton 186cm, Dunstall 188cm, Lockett 191cm, Carey 192cm, Lloyd 192cm). It's so weird to me the fixation now for the 196cm+ forwards who are ultra mobile and athletic. Seems that most of them end up breaking down regularly and hate body contact.

Anti density rules that were introduced into U18 competition a few years ago have had a big bearing on a young key forwards ability to stand up and win their position at the elite level. While these rules encourage the kids to learn winning one on one battles and showcase their skills in open space, the reality is AFL key forwards don’t usually get many of those one on one opportunities.
When the kids come up to the seniors, they don’t know what’s hit them ( literally ) when 100 kilo men surround them and then simply block them from competing. The young blokes have to be something very special to make it as a key forward these days and most generally spend a year or two being re trained to learn the position for the AFL.
You don’t need to be 200cm tall to hold down full forward but you really do need to know how to use your body to get in position to protect the ball drop ( which is why Armstrong is easily the best key forward in this draft ) Anything less and your time in the big league will be short lived.

Nate Caddy 194cm and Jed Walter 195 are very recent examples of key forwards who managed to break the mould and already look up to the level as 19 year olds. Both were top 10 picks.

[Presti35]

Waterman has signed a 5 year deal to stay at WCE. Dees were the ones who made a play for him. They've missed out again.

[Pies4shaw]

^ Great - they'll probably spend the whole of 2025 with an 8 goal per game forward line, too.

[The Black and White Lion]

Now that the Swans have imploded and been smashed in a second GF in 3 years, I’m guessing there could be a few regrets signing up everyone on big deals so early and there could be a few players wanting out.

Could Dean Cox could flip to the Weagles now? Does Longmire go early and leave Cox the reigns?

Could Chad Warner want out next year for Freo. We’ve heard rumours of Parker to the Roos. Is it Lloyd or Cunningham who’s an unsigned UFA?

Are there any other Swans players that we could target now this year or next to make us better?

[SLORT]

^Logan McDonald? Oh yeah...that's right...he preferred the Swan-dive.

[Pies4shaw]

Are there any other Swans players that we could target now this year or next to make us better?

[Mr Miyagi]

Tay Adams might request a trade back to us

[piedys]

^No worries; throw in Gulden or McInerney and it's a deal.

[Presti35]

^Logan McDonald? Oh yeah...that's right...he preferred the Swan-dive.

Very selfish to run out today. If he knew he wasn't 100%, then he should have pulled the pin. Horse didnt learn from when he played Reid a few years back. If there is doubt, you dont play them.

[Presti35]

Sydney Players Out of Contract in 2024:
Aaron Francis - Non-Free Agent
Caleb Mitchell - Non-Free Agent
Cooper Vickery - Non-Free Agent
Harry Arnold - Non-Free Agent
Jacob Konstanty - Non-Free Agent
Jaiden Magor - Non-Free Agent
Lachlan McAndrew - Non-Free Agent
Tom Hanily - Non-Free Agent

Nothing to see here.