Maynard incident > Maynard rule > Brayshaw retirement

[pietillidie]

Absolutely no one should be feeling grateful that the right, reasonable and fair decision was made. Glad perhaps that scumbags, halfwits and puerile sore losers like Goodwin didn't have their way, but not grateful that reasonable people behaved reasonably.

The case itself wasn't complex. The wider issues are complex, but the purposeful conflation of the two was malicious, not accidental, for all but the slowest drivers.

[Mr Miyagi]

Maynard cleared but the vitriol and vilification continues. Herald Sun calls it an injustice and calls for AFL to appeal. Hate to say this, but I think this mud is going to stick to Bruz, and the club, for a long time.

[Greening gold]

[think positive]

Maynard cleared but the vitriol and vilification continues. Herald Sun calls it an injustice and calls for AFL to appeal. Hate to say this, but I think this mud is going to stick to Bruz, and the club, for a long time.

Nah, only people who know nothing about sport,footy in particular, or who hate Collingwood could really thin he was guilty, **** em

[23 YIPPEE!!!]

Do we think that the AFL will appeal they have till close of business tomorrow afternoon

[Damien]

As above, Greg Baum has probably summed it up a little more articulately as a professional journalist than we have as a group.

The AFL had to act for their own protection and that’s why they put this straight to the Tribunal. The AFL will have to suck this up. They won’t risk further embarrassment by appealing.

Let Footy now make the headlines, not legal/tribunal stuff.

[Piesnchess]

I wonder how sore loser goofy Goodwin is feeling now, meh, who cares. lol

[David]

Do we think that the AFL will appeal they have till close of business tomorrow afternoon

For what it’s worth, Whateley (who’s copped a fair bit of flak in this thread, much of it unfairly I think) responded with a decisive "no" to that question on AFL 360. He reckons the tribunal’s verdict is thorough and compelling, and sees no room for the AFL to have cause for complaint.

[scoobydoo]

Maynard cleared but the vitriol and vilification continues. Herald Sun calls it an injustice and calls for AFL to appeal. Hate to say this, but I think this mud is going to stick to Bruz, and the club, for a long time.

Mate it’s the HS,

[Piesnchess]

I am going to make a point of listening to bit of SEN radio tomorrow, going by last night, be highly amusing listening to all the sore loser Deeeees fans ringing in, spewing,spitting bile. One woman last night was nigh on hysterical, ranted and raved, furious, oh it made my day, heaing their pissing and moaning.

[jonmac1954]

AFL will decide tomorrow morning whether to appeal or not.

https://twitter.com/cleary_mitch/status ... wsrc%5Etfw

IT wont no way Jose, they have been totally ****, egg all over their faces, that Lana hot shot lawyer, has made them look lke total village idiots, they wont drag this on now, its gone on for too long now, torn fans apart, its over, they know its over, done and dusted, they would not have a leg to dtand on anyway, its done.

Sorry Lana didn't make them look like village idiots.

They are village idiots . . .

And way down the bottom of the village idiot scale at that.

[What'sinaname]

And just when you think you've seen all the village idiots.....Eddie pops us.

What a idiot he is.

[Mr Miyagi]

Premiership Eagle Will Schofield, who said the AFL should appeal the tribunal’s call, wrote on X: “In the end, where you sit on this Maynard tribunal decision comes down to whether you like Collingwood or not. Let’s be honest.”

To which Bucks replied, “ or you can have some integrity.” Mic drop!!!

https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/teams/ ... 78fab3a20e

[Mr Miyagi]

We’re on page 42. Let’s lock the thread on this great number and what it means to the club. Carn the Pies!

Dammit, 43.

[mattdally]

Laura Kane. What a massive mistake. Resign now before you get sacked. 0-2 to start your career.