Maynard incident > Maynard rule > Brayshaw retirement

[K]

Can anyone here clear this up?

I'm assuming the tribunal tonight will be run and judged by the AFL?

If so, he will get weeks. The AFL obviously want to make a statement, hence over riding MRO. Now, they have done their bit to condone concussions and therefore not get sued down the track.

If this happens, we obviously appeal. I assume it will be an independent legal body? If so, hopefully common sense prevails and Bruz is cleared.

"The AFL"

Gillon/Dillon (old/new CEO) & Laura Kane (new executive general manager).

They went over the top of Michael Christian (match review officer), who threatened to resign in protest.

AFL Tribunal

Tribunal Chairs: Jeffrey Gleeson KC, Renee Enbom KC
Tribunal Panel Members: Michelle Dench, Wayne Henwood, Jason Johnson, Stephen Jurica, Richard Loveridge, Stewart Loewe, Shannon McFerran, David Neitz, Paul Williams, Shane Wakelin, Talia Radan, Darren Gaspar, Jordan Bannister, Scott Stevens.

Appeals Board

Appeal Board Chairs: Murray Kellam KC, John Middleton.
Appeal Board Panel Members: Wayne Henwood, Stephen Jurica, Richard Loveridge

AFL Tribunal Counsel: Nick Pane KC, Andrew Woods, Sally Flynn KC, Lisa Hannon KC, Sam Bird

[Piesnchess]

Take it all the way to the friggin Supreme Court, Carlton would.

[jonmac1954]

Take it all the way to the friggin Supreme Court, Carlton would.

Amen comrade.

The Gillon era has seen Collingwood become the target of choice.

The corporate media has seen this and taken advantage of the fact there is no hit back from the ALF - which is supposed to represent ALL teams - the sooner that POS gets out of office the better.

[Mr Miyagi]

But according to Hamish Brayshaw, the AFL is rigging the comp for us to win the flag!

[Damien]

Take it all the way to the friggin Supreme Court, Carlton would.

Can you still go to the Privy Council in London. Just get it adjourned until November.

[maurs64]

If Maynard is suspended, I want the AFL to suspend EVERY player that causes a concussion! And that includes players that concuss their OWN teammates! Every action that causes concussion is careless & can be called unduly rough play. Also why not suspend every player that causes broken bones, knee injuries, shoulder injuries, etc. Why is it just concussion that is punished? Shouldn't tunnelling be reportable by now?

[K]

...
AFL Tribunal

Tribunal Chairs: Jeffrey Gleeson KC, Renee Enbom KC
Tribunal Panel Members: Michelle Dench, Wayne Henwood, Jason Johnson, Stephen Jurica, Richard Loveridge, Stewart Loewe, Shannon McFerran, David Neitz, Paul Williams, Shane Wakelin, Talia Radan, Darren Gaspar, Jordan Bannister, Scott Stevens.

...

Starts in 25 minutes...

The three for tonight are: Jeff Gleeson, Stewart Loewe, Jason Johnson.

[Piesnchess]

If Maynard is suspended, I want the AFL to suspend EVERY player that causes a concussion! And that includes players that concuss their OWN teammates! Every action that causes concussion is careless & can be called unduly rough play. Also why not suspend every player that causes broken bones, knee injuries, shoulder injuries, etc. Why is it just concussion that is punished? Shouldn't tunnelling be reportable by now?

As Cornes said , it will/ could mean the end of the high shoulder mark cos the player flying for the Speccy, invariably bangs his knee , hard, into the players head down below, sometimes very hard indeed. HOW much concussion will THAT cause, hey ????? Oh an if Bruzza does go , it could mean the end of the smother also, no player will risk a quick smother anymore. for sure, its a precedent then.

The game is becoming basketball now, at a rate of knots.

[jonmac1954]

If Maynard is suspended, I want the AFL to suspend EVERY player that causes a concussion! And that includes players that concuss their OWN teammates! Every action that causes concussion is careless & can be called unduly rough play. Also why not suspend every player that causes broken bones, knee injuries, shoulder injuries, etc. Why is it just concussion that is punished? Shouldn't tunnelling be reportable by now?

As Cornes said , it will/ could mean the end of the high shoulder mark cos the player flying for the Speccy, invariably bangs his knee , hard, into the players head down below, sometimes very hard indeed. HOW much concussion will THAT cause, hey ????? Oh an if Bruzza does go , it could mean the end of the smother also, no player will risk a quick smother anymore. for sure, its a precedent then.

The game is becoming basketball now, at a rate of knots.

Total agreement and Bruz epitomizes what contact sport should be all about. Hard at the ball and the opponent with the ball, no malice it's business.

[Mr Miyagi]

If Maynard is suspended, I want the AFL to suspend EVERY player that causes a concussion! And that includes players that concuss their OWN teammates! Every action that causes concussion is careless & can be called unduly rough play. Also why not suspend every player that causes broken bones, knee injuries, shoulder injuries, etc. Why is it just concussion that is punished? Shouldn't tunnelling be reportable by now?

I want BT suspended because he gives me a migraine!

Pendies on radio made a good point. Will knees to the back of the head when players jump for a mark get looked at?

[Piesnchess]

This trial by media circus Inquisition starts soon, does it not ? Goodluck Bruzza.

[jonmac1954]

This trial by media circus Inquisition starts soon, does it not ? Goodluck Bruzza.

Starts 4pm apparently.

[the fuzz]

Good luck Bruzz! Good luck everyone!

[jonmac1954]

The AFL will be furious with the MFC tweet about Brayshaw running. Hope we ram it down their throats and watch them squirm.

[think positive]

7 min, how long does it take to say dismissed!