This is an unofficial Bulletin Board - owned and run by its users. We welcome all fans of the Mighty Collingwood Football Club.
Ad blocker detected: Our website is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors. Please consider supporting us by disabling your ad blocker on our website.
This is a Collingwood Bulletin Board - use this forum for general, Pies-related topics. For other footy topics, use Nick's Other AFL forum, and for non-footy sporting topics please use Nick's Sports Bar. For non-sporting topics please use the Victoria Park Tavern.
everybody miss that daisy should have had 50 paid against him?
The cat dropped the ball trying to get a 50, no way should that have been given, Thomas was pushing him back from his mark. If that had been one of our boys and it was given 50 we'd all be jumping the fence.
Thomas pushed him sideways.
Of course we would but to the letter of the law it was there!
Lonergan may or may not have dropped the ball but if dildo daisy doesn't put his hands on him there cannot be a question.
Stupied wrote:So many references to the Menzel non-free at the end of the game. I was actually applauding the umpires for putting the whistle away in those dying moments, because every scum player that grabbed the ball was trying to barrel head first into a cats player to draw a free, including Menzel. The umpires saw it and acted accordingly.
The push in the back call against Waite for that tackle and the play on call against Hawkins while he was in the middle of his run up were both abortions of calls though.
Bingo
As much as I hate Tom Harley, my haterd of Carlolton is greater.
He could barely keep a straight face as he continued to say that Menzel should have been a free- Wayne "face like a tranny' Carey looked at hime and almost cracked up laughing.
harley straight trolling Carlolton
Also, is it common practice for Bruce not to be on panel after game?
Or is it just when his beloved blues lose??
Looking at the Menzel, Robinson non frees I think the decisions were correct (having said that I will take great joy in saying to my Carlton friends that the frees were obviously there)
Menzel looked like he ploughed into the stationery player hoping to draw the free. It is my pet hate when players try to draw the free. One day someone is going to get seriously injured doing this.
As for Robinson, the ball was going to be bounced and he was merely walking to position. No impact on the play at all.
Was rather funny, thought they might have pulled off an upset when Gibbs kicked that goal in the last. 2 weeks running of 3 goals up with 5 minutes left and they can't close the deal. Micks presser was funny also, sucked in bloozers!
P.S Matrix10-how's life in the FastLane?!
Wayne Campbell from umps dept confirmed that Menzel should have got free for over the shoulder, but umpire was correct not to guess as he was not in a position to see the free kick.
Also said that Mitch Robinson was not entitled to free as runner had not influenced play.
Funkadelic wrote:Was rather funny, thought they might have pulled off an upset when Gibbs kicked that goal in the last. 2 weeks running of 3 goals up with 5 minutes left and they can't close the deal. Micks presser was funny also, sucked in bloozers!
P.S Matrix10-how's life in the FastLane?!
